top of page
  • Writer's pictureBobbi Jo Lathan

Aunt Noni's Fresh Pumpkin Pie

Updated: Oct 31, 2023

Aunt Noni’s fresh pumpkin is soooo much better tasting than that ol’ bright

orange-lookin’ store-bought stuff in a can. This recipe from my Aunt Noni comes out a

rich, brownish-orange color and cooks up beautifully. AND, this mixture can be frozen and

used all year round in all your pies, cakes, and breads and muffins that require



25 min


45 min


1 medium-sized or 4 small-sized sugar pumpkins (cut and inner seed-stringy pulp

scraped out)

¾ cup sugar

½ cup evaporated milk

1 teaspoon vanilla

½ teaspoon salt

4 eggs, beaten

½ teaspoon each of ground

cloves, ground cinnamon,

freshly ground nutmeg

3 tablespoons butter, melted


1. Cut the fresh pumpkin into manageable slices (like a cantaloupe

slice), cut off the outer skin, and cut into 3-inch pieces. Put the

peeled pumpkin chunks into a pot of boiling water (like you would

boil potatoes) and boil until tender, about 20 minutes, until soft. You can also

steam the pumpkin, if you like, until soft.

2. Once the pumpkin is soft, drain it in a colander in your kitchen sink.

3. After it has been sitting in the colander about 10 minutes, VERY GENTLY press

the pumpkin down into the colander with a big spoon to get all the

extra water out.

4. After it’s drained, put the boiled (or steamed) pumpkin into a bowl and mash it like

you would mashed potatoes, and again, pour off any extra juice. And, there’s

your fresh pumpkin! SOOO much better than that ol’ canned stuff!

5. Measure out 2 cups of the freshly mashed pumpkin and place it in

a big mixing bowl. Then, mix and whisk in all the rest of the ingredients listed above,

until it’s blended. Keep doing this until you use up all of the pumpkin.

NOTE: Now, if you’re still in a hurry, just buy yourself a store-bought frozen deep-dish

pie crust already in the pan (or packaged frozen pie crust dough that you roll out and

place it in your pie pan) flute the edges, fork some pricks in the crust, fill the pie shell

with your beautiful FRESH pumpkin mixture and bake at 350ᵒ for 30-40 minutes (‘til it

doesn’t jiggle in the middle) and it turns that beautiful rich brown color. YUM!


Recent Posts

See All


bottom of page